Wind Energy News
WIND DAILY
UK campaigners in green energy standoff reject 'nimby' label
UK campaigners in green energy standoff reject 'nimby' label
By Helen ROWE
Friston, United Kingdom (AFP) Sept 19, 2024

With its medieval church and picturesque village green, the tranquil hamlet of Friston in eastern England should be an unlikely place for a showdown with the UK government and an energy giant.

But Friston, population 341, is on the frontline of a bitter green energy battle between locals in the rural county of Suffolk and those who want to locate a vast energy hub there.

If the plans by National Grid -- backed by both the new Labour government and its Conservative predecessor -- go ahead, it will see the area transformed by steel and concrete for onshore substations.

Undersea cables from offshore windfarms would make landfall somewhere on the nearby coastline before being sent a few kilometres inland via huge "cable trenches", requiring years of disruptive construction work.

The government wants to decarbonise electricity supply by 2030. The Suffolk campaigners back that transition to renewables.

They warn, however, that current plans to bring green energy from offshore wind turbines into the grid via the planned infrastructure will be an ecological and tourism "catastrophe".

Thousands of jobs in Suffolk depend on the year-round visitors who flock to the county's beaches, coastal resorts and unspoilt countryside.

The area is particularly renowned for its protected birdlife.

Opposition to the plans could certainly appear to be driven by "nimbyism" -- the opposition to something being built or done in your local community, even if it has to be done elsewhere.

Suffolk residents are understandably keen to preserve their rural haven.

But the campaigners, who believe offshore infrastructure would both be less destructive and more efficient, argue the issues are far bigger.

- 'Laughed at' -

"We've been laughed at, because they say we're just nimbys. We've been mocked," said Fiona Gilmore, a former strategic adviser to emerging market countries, who set up the Suffolk Energy Action Solutions (SEAS) campaign group in 2019.

Branding her and other critics of the scheme "nimbys" -- or "not in my backyard" -- is just a convenient way of dismissing their justifiable concerns for nature and the environment, she added.

Those include the irreversible potential destruction of acres of heathland, habitat, coastline and wetland.

Adam Rowlands, of the bird protection body RSPB, said the dispute was far more than "just a local issue" and posed a real risk to the nearby North Warren nature reserve.

"A nationally important population spends the winter on those marshes," he said.

The RSPB "absolutely sees the need to transform our energy grid and infrastructure", he added.

"But we need to do that in a way that doesn't exacerbate the biodiversity crisis," he said, adding that offshore options also had disadvantages for marine ecology that had to be considered.

SEAS argues that the UK's North Sea neighbours such as Denmark, Germany, the Netherlands and Belgium are already building offshore hubs and that these could work for the UK too.

The actor Ralph Fiennes, who spent his early childhood on the Suffolk coast, has thrown his support behind the drive for offshore alternatives.

"Yes, yes, yes to green power a million times over, the planet is lost without it," said Fiennes in a short film he made highlighting the ecological cost of the plans.

"But our very real human connection to the coast that defines us will be undermined and eroded unless we... implement that vital green power with a forward-thinking and environmentally enlightened vision," he said.

Net Zero Secretary Ed Miliband, however, this week appeared to reject campaigners' pleas for a pause to reconsider the plans.

On Tuesday he vowed to "take on the blockers, the delayers, the obstructionists" to build clean energy infrastructure.

- 'Not listened to' -

The campaigners say they have been shaken by the way they have been treated by a system they describe as "not fit for purpose".

Despite spending hours preparing submissions for the various hearings organised as part of the planning process, Gilmore said the overwhelming impression campaigners had was of "not being listened to".

And she said the mental health issues for those caught up in the row were "massive".

People in Friston, near the market town of Saxmundham, "have been living with this nightmare hanging over them for over five years", she said.

"You can't just treat people like this."

Fellow campaigner Charlotte Fox, a retired intensive care anaesthetist, said she initially accepted National Grid's decision, believing it and the government were working in the national interest.

But after doing some research she said she concluded that there was now a "perfectly viable alternative option that is cheaper, better, faster" without the destruction that would be caused by what she considers an outdated scheme.

"What is the point of causing all this destruction and damaging the biodiversity that we are trying to save in the first place?"

har/phz/gv/lb

NATIONAL GRID

Related Links
Wind Energy News at Wind Daily

Subscribe Free To Our Daily Newsletters
Tweet

RELATED CONTENT
The following news reports may link to other Space Media Network websites.
WIND DAILY
Wind turbine orders grow 23 percent, led by China: study
Paris (AFP) Sept 16, 2024
Dominated by China, orders for wind turbines increased 23 percent worldwide in the first half of the year, with investment reaching $42 billion, an energy research firm said on Monday. Out of a global total of 91.2 gigawatts (GW), Chinese domestic orders alone represented 70 GW while orders from abroad added another 5 GW, said research firm Wood Mackenzie in a press release Monday. "Chinese OEMs (original equipment manufacturers) continue to break records for order intake," said Luke Lewandowski ... read more

WIND DAILY
Czechs to develop small nuclear reactors with Rolls-Royce

GE Vernova advances SMR technology in the UK through strategic MoUs

South Korea approves building two nuclear reactors

Power struggle: Serbia eyes nuclear energy to fuel future

WIND DAILY
Turning seawater into fresh water using solar-powered technology'

Airbus to Provide Over 200 Sparkwing Solar Arrays for MDA AURORA Satellites

JinkoSolar sets sights on expanding operations across Africa

University of Michigan develops efficient system for converting CO2 into ethylene

WIND DAILY
Electrochemical cell converts captured carbon to green fuel with high efficiency

Using sunlight to recycle harmful gases into valuable products

New study highlights improved ethanol production method using CO2 and Nanocatalysts

Biomethane Production on Peat Soils Leads to Higher CO2 Emissions than Natural Gas

WIND DAILY
2024 Global Methane Report shows significant growth in emissions

Human remains found in SUV that triggered Texas gas pipeline fire

Azerbaijan says 'God-given' oil and gas will help it go green

Pennsylvania's fracking industry plans to continue, whoever wins White House

WIND DAILY
World Bank boosts climate financing by 10 percent

Climate finance: what you need to know ahead of COP29

Energy companies have spent $5.6 bn on 'sportswashing': report

UK agrees public control of key electricity operator

WIND DAILY
New organic thermoelectric device generates energy at room temperature

Harnessing the ocean's potential for clean energy development

Folded or cut, this lithium-sulfur battery keeps powering devices

Second life of lithium-ion batteries may propel future space missions

WIND DAILY
EU, China hold 'constructive' talks on EV tariffs

Thousands protest in Brussels as EV troubles threaten Audi plant

European auto industry urges assistance ahead of rule tightening

Chinese electronics group Luxshare swoops on German parts-maker Leoni

WIND DAILY
Sustainable mulch films aim to boost agriculture and reduce plastic waste

Report links meatpacking companies to 'war on nature' in Brazil

Vietnam farmers lose their blooms as floods claim crops

Deadly floods bring relief to Moroccan farmers

Subscribe Free To Our Daily Newsletters




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2024 - Space Media Network. All websites are published in Australia and are solely subject to Australian law and governed by Fair Use principals for news reporting and research purposes. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA news reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. All articles labeled "by Staff Writers" include reports supplied to Space Media Network by industry news wires, PR agencies, corporate press officers and the like. Such articles are individually curated and edited by Space Media Network staff on the basis of the report's information value to our industry and professional readership. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) Statement Our advertisers use various cookies and the like to deliver the best ad banner available at one time. All network advertising suppliers have GDPR policies (Legitimate Interest) that conform with EU regulations for data collection. By using our websites you consent to cookie based advertising. If you do not agree with this then you must stop using the websites from May 25, 2018. Privacy Statement. Additional information can be found here at About Us.